top of page
  • Twitter
  • Spotify
  • Apple Music

Selection Sunday Survival Guide: Breaking Down the FCS Playoff Bubble

Writer: Madison McCord
Madison McCord
2 minutes ago
5 min read

My 6-year-old daughter is going to be really upset when she learns the topic of this week’s column is bubbles and she doesn’t get to play with them. 😂


But her disappointment isn’t close to what some teams will be feeling in less than a week’s time after the FCS Playoff bracket is released Sunday morning by the NCAA. 24 spots, lots of excitement, even more disappointment. But who will be feeling that jubilation when the field is announced?


To start, we need to look at who is already a lock to make the postseason.


Five teams have already secured their conference titles and an auto-bid into the field. Monmouth (CAA), Harvard (Ivy), South Dakota State (MVFC), Lehigh (Patriot) and Tarleton State (UAC) are all in for sure. That leaves six more conference champions to be crowned this final weekend of the regular season in the Big Sky, NEC, OVC, Pioneer, SoCon and Southland.


There are also the MEAC and SWAC champions, but those conference winners opt out of auto-bids for spots in the Celebration Bowl and SWAC Championship game instead.


The betting favorites, or those teams with the easiest path, to earn those final auto-bid spots are Montana State, Central Connecticut State, Southeast Missouri State, Dayton, Mercer/East Tennessee State and Lamar.


That slash between Mercer and ETSU makes for the weekend’s most interesting clash, as it’s the only game this weekend where regardless of other outcomes, the winner will take the conference crown. I see Mercer making the field regardless, but an ETSU loss puts the Buccaneers firmly into bubble territory and likely on the outside looking in due to a lack of quality wins.


Once those 11 spots are locked though, and for the purpose of this exercise we will assume the rest of the bids will be filled by the favorites and Mercer, we can turn to the 13 at-large selections.


The Locks


Even if these teams tumble in the final weekend, they’ll be playing this postseason. All that could change in this final weekend is seeding.


Youngstown State is done with their regular-season slate, only playing 11 games and ending with a 34-33 stunning loss to Illinois State last Saturday. Even without playing this weekend though, YSU is in. Although their chances of a top four seed took a massive hit.


Northern Arizona, South Dakota, Montana, Stephen F. Austin and North Dakota are also in. The interesting thing to watch this weekend is finding out which teams will get a top 8 seed and a first-round bye.


Montana has by far the toughest contest of this group of teams, taking on top-ranked Montana State. A win would secure a bye for the Griz, but a loss puts them in the 10-12 seed range. USD also has a tough test against Illinois State, who is firmly in the bubble conversation.


The odd one in this group is Tennessee Tech. A win and they might vault into a top-8 seed discussion being that they finish their season against SEC foe Mississippi State. But the Golden Eagles are already at nine FCS wins and have secured their postseason spot.


That brings the count to 18 teams and six spots to fill.


Win and They're In


Illinois State has a tough test against South Dakota, but if the Redbirds can win and reach eight FCS victories, they’ll be in for sure. Weber State is also in with a win over Utah Tech following their victory last weekend over NAU.


Also, on the win-and-in side of things Austin Peay, which is coming off a tough loss to Lamar and just needs to top Central Arkansas to reach nine FCS wins. Just three spots left.


On the Bubble


Starting on the west coast and heading east, all eyes this weekend should be on UC Davis, Idaho State, Abilene Christian, Incarnate Word, Campbell, UAlbany and Bryant.


In the Big Sky, UC Davis hosts Cal Poly and is looking to earn its eighth FCS win after toppling Idaho last weekend in the Kibbie Dome. The Aggies haven’t looked particularly impressive at times this season, but eight wins is tough to keep out of the postseason. For Idaho State, they’ll host the Vandals on Saturday for a chance to get to seven D1 wins, including a victory at FBS Utah State. The knock on the Bengals though? No ranked FCS wins.


ACU has been red-hot to end the season, including a win over Austin Peay last weekend. The Wildcats finish against 3-8 Eastern Kentucky and are looking to reach the seven FCS win mark. ACU also has played a brutal schedule, including games against Stephen F. Austin, Lamar, Idaho, Mercer, Tarleton State and Austin Peay.


Incarnate Word is another late-surging squad, currently on a five-game winning streak. A victory Saturday over East Texas A&M would put UIW at eight wins, but only seven of them are D1 and none against ranked foes.


Campbell was the bell of the ball in the FCS a month ago, but since then it’s been a tough go for the Camels.


Campbell has lost two of its last three against UAlbany and Elon, but a win Saturday against CAA champion Monmouth would be massive in pushing Campbell into a seed.


Last is UAlbany and Bryant, which are both at seven FCS wins, but neither has played a particularly tough schedule. The Great Danes’ best win is over fellow bubble team Campbell, while Bryant’s best win was topping UAlbany 31-7 two weeks ago.


If the committee felt not enough of those teams were worth and somehow wanted to dip into the six-or-seven-win pool, Idaho, if they beat ISU and nab their third ranked win, Chattanooga, North Alabama, Princeton and Elon stand out as the best options.


At the end of the day, assuming this weekend goes as the oddsmakers expect, this is how I see the field shaping up (by conference, not seed).


  • Big Sky (5): Montana State, Northern Arizona, Montana, Weber State, UC Davis

  • CAA (1): Monmouth

  • Ivy (1): Harvard

  • MVFC (5): South Dakota State, Youngstown State, South Dakota, North Dakota, Illinois State

  • NEC (1): Central Connecticut State

  • OVC (1): Southeast Missouri State

  • Patriot (1): Lehigh

  • Pioneer (1): Dayton

  • SoCon (2): Mercer, Tennessee Tech

  • Southland (3): Lamar, Stephen F. Austin, Incarnate Word

  • UAC (3): Tarleton State, Austin Peay, Abilene Christian


This could be perfect, I could miss five teams that get in! The only ones that know what will really happen is the selection committee, and we will find that out all together on Sunday.


Wofford Hires Former Champ Mike Houston as HC



Former FCS champion coach Mike Houston has landed his next job as the coach of the Wofford Terriers.


Houston, who was most recently on the support staff at Clemson, won an FCS title with James Madison in 2016.


Following the 2018 campaign, Houston moved to FBS East Carolina where he went 27-38 in five seasons.


Houston also appeared to be a favorite to land the open head coaching job at Furman, but a deal didn’t come together due to a disagreement on revenue-sharing plans, according to FootballScoop.

Comments


bottom of page